MultiMechanics Blog

What do the Model T and F-150 have in common? Advanced Materials!

Posted by MultiMechanics on Mar 24, 2015 2:23:00 PM

Henry Ford's Model T is on the verge of its 107th Birthday.  As we all know, the Model T was the first and most popular mass produced automobile in the world.  The Model T was introduced on Oct. 1, 1908 and by 1921, Ford Model Ts accounted for over half of the world’s automobile production.  

1910Ford-T

The car was lauded for the revolutionary process by which it was manufactured (the moving assembly line), but the auto itself was an engineering marvel.  Lets take a look back at this industry inventing automobile, and the technologies and materials that made it possible.  

It Starts With A Vision

inflationThe goal of Henry Ford was to make an automobile for the great masses.  For this reason he needed to make the car as cheap, durable, rugged, and fuel-efficient as possible - truly a challenging optimization problem.

When The Model T was introduced in 1908 for $825, which wasn't that inexpensive considering a teacher's annual salary at the time was $850.  Over the course of 19 years,  dramatic improvements in manufacturing efficiency and supply chain integration lowered the cost to only $280  (which is equivalent to $3,727.17 in 2015).

On a side note, over the past 30 years, the average car price has diverged from the normalized compound inflation curve,  to the point that the average price of a car is now $32,000 (10x the cost of a 1920 Model T).  This divergence is largely due to the introduction of advanced safety features and electronics. That said, the cheapest American car is the Nissan Versa at about  $11,000 ($885 in 1920 - about 3x the cost of a Model T).

Material Innovation

The Model T weighted about 1200 lbs, had a 100in wheelbase, and a 10 gallon gas tank.  It got about 13 to 21 miles per gallon of gasoline but because gasoline was not widely available in the early days of automobiles, the Model T was designed to run on gas, grain alcohol, or ethanol.

Despite it’s nickname “The Tin Lizzy”, a Model T’s bill-of-materials included Iron, Wood, and (for structurally crucial components), steel - but no Tin. The fender and most engine components were made of high strength iron.  The body panels were composed of a framework of wood to which cheap sheet steel was fastened. But, undoubtedly, the most breakthrough material of the car was Vanadium Steel

vanadium

Henry Ford searched the world for the best materials he could find at the cheapest cost.  In 1905, during a car race in Florida, he noticed that the parts of a wrecked French sports car were lighter but stronger than what was being used in mass-produced American vehicles. This French concoction was known as Vanadium Steel.

Ford recognized that, despite it’s higher price tag, the steel's high tensile strength (nearly three times greater than cheaper, lower-grade steels), and its ability to be easily machined would allow him to make a stronger, lighter, better performing car.  As part of the pre-production process for the Model T, Ford imported an expert who helped the company build a steel mill and mass produce the metal.  

Vanadium steel eventually was used in nearly all of the Model T's highly stressed parts including the crankshaft, forged front axle, wheel spindles, springs, and transmission gears (vanadium steel running in an oil bath). Steel was a critical, albeit very heavy, component. 

Same Problems, Different Day

Fast forward 100 years, on modern vehicles, most of the weight still comes from different varieties of steel.  In 2007, the average car weighed 3,000 lbs and contained 2,400 lbs of steel.  The average truck weighed 4,000 lbs and contained 3,000 lbs of steel.  In cars, steel is used to create the underlying chassis, exhaust pipes, door beams, roofs and body panels.

But - due to tighter fuel efficiency regulations, the trend is towards lighter, more expensive materials. Just as Henry Ford sacrificed price for performance, engineers in today’s car company’s are forced to make the same crucial decisions.

Ford at it Again

Fords

In 2015, Ford overhauled its iconic F-150 pickup, replacing the truck’s steel body panels with lightweight aluminum, and shed 400 pounds in the process.

Aluminum costs 3x as much as steel but is more malleable and elastic, more corrosion resistant, and up to 3x lighter than steel. That said, aluminum (like other advanced materials) cannot be manufactured using the same age-old techniques. Aluminum must be riveted and bonded with adhesives, requiring new equipment, processes and suppliers.  Time spent on factory retooling will equate to about 90,000 less F-150 trucks on the road this year, which adds up to $3.6 billion in lost revenue for Ford.  Like Henry did 100 years prior, Ford believes these capital expenditures will pay dividends for years to come.

Because of the switch to aluminum, the Ford F150 was able to shed 400 pounds (10% weight reduction). For every 10 percent reduction in vehicle weight, fuel economy increases 5-7 percent and the F150 2015 exceeded that by improving MPG by 7.4%.

Because of the increased cost of aluminum, this 400 lb reduction adds about $725 to the raw material costs of the truck.  However, due to advanced recycling practices spurred by former CEO Alan Mulally, about $280 of this additional cost gets recovered during recycling.

Another pleasantly surprising outcome of the lightweighting effort, is that it allowed Ford to scale back on parts that were introduced to account for the car’s excess weight. For instance, the F-150 uses a smaller but powerful 2.7-liter Ecoboost engine option, smaller brakes and a lighter suspension.  These updates further reduced truck costs and improved its fuel economy. 

"Black" Aluminum

Today's cars also use tremendous amounts of plastics in auto manufacturing. They make up about 50 percent of the construction of new cars today by volume - but mostly for non-structural components. It's not surprising because traditional plastics are durable, cheap and can be turned into just about anything

A new trend, however, is to use high-cost, high-performance fiber-reinforced plastics (pejoratively referred to as "Black Aluminum"). While the F-150 reduced a lot of weight, it still uses heavy steel for many components like the cage and chassis. Daring companies like Hyundai are looking into carbon fiber car frames which would reduce frame weight by 70% and vehicle weight by 30%, without compromising on rigidity or safety features.

JEC_Hyundai


Bonus Fact: Henry Ford, a bastion of efficiency, used wood scraps from the production of Model Ts to make charcoal, which he then sold.  Originally named Ford Charcoal, the name was later changed to Kingsford Charcoal.

 

  MultiMechOpener

Topics: automotive, advanced materials